Menu Close

Comparison of Vertex42 Checkbook vs Excel-Checkbook.com

Before I made my own checkbook register spreadsheet, I explored popular free checkbook templates, including those offered by Vertex42.

Vertex42 Checkbook Register Template

This free checkbook register is one of the first that I checked out.

Vertex42 checkbook register

What’s to Like about the Vertex42 Checkbook Register (Pros)

  • Provides a clean, simple, easy to use register
  • Gives a visual warning when your balance drops below a chosen value that you can set
  • Offers a drop-down for date selection when entering a transaction, and you aren’t blocked from entering a date that’s not in the drop-down list
  • There’s no issue with the balance formula if you insert or delete a row in the register (a common issue with other checkbook registers)
  • Offers a basic reconciliation feature
  • Free!

What’s Not to Like about the Vertex42 Checkbook Template (Cons)

  • There’s too much area taken up at top of worksheet with content that is always visible.
  • The formula for balance uses the OFFSET function which causes significant performance issues when your spreadsheet gets larger
  • When you insert a new row, the font formatting doesn’t match with existing rows, so you have to manually fix each new row
  • You can categorize your transactions but there are no charts or reports for analysis of your expenses
  • There’s only one register worksheet
  • You can’t split a transaction across different categories
  • If you create copies of the original register worksheet for additional bank accounts, there’s no way to consolidate or view everything in a summarized report or chart

Note: there’s another website called ExcelTemplates.com which offers a nearly identical spreadsheet as Vertex42 file. The same author? Or is it a stolen template from Vertex42?

If you’re looking for a very basic free checkbook template, Vertex42 is worth a look. But if you want something with more features and/or you want features that are similar to Quicken without Quicken’s monthly subscription cost, check out the checkbook templates here.

Competitive Differentiation for Excel-Checkbook.com

  • Depth of features (categories, sub-categories, dashboard, reports, bank import)
  • Email support from a real person
  • Small business version
  • Privacy-first (no bank account linking)

Discover more from Excel Checkbook

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *